Judge in Manafort Case Says Mueller Wants Info on Trump - NECN
National & International News
The day’s top national and international news

Judge in Manafort Case Says Mueller Wants Info on Trump

"You really care about wanting information you could get from Mr. Manafort that would relate to Mr. Trump and lead to his prosecution, or impeachment, or whatever," U.S. Senior Judge T.S. Ellis III said

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Judge in Manafort Case Says Mueller Wants Info on Trump
    AP
    Paul Manafort departs Federal District Court for a hearing, Thursday, April 19, 2018, in Washington.

    A federal judge on Friday asked pointed questions about special counsel Robert Mueller's authority to bring charges against former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort and suggested that prosecutors' true motive is getting Manafort to "sing" against the president.

    Manafort's lawyers argued at a hearing in Alexandria that the tax and bank fraud charges are far afield from Mueller's mandate to investigate Russian meddling in the 2016 election and whether any collusion occurred.

    "I don't see what relationship this indictment has with what the special counsel is investigating," U.S. Senior Judge T.S. Ellis III, a Reagan appointee, told government lawyers at Friday's hearing.

    The Virginia indictment alleges Manafort hid tens of millions of dollars he earned advising pro-Russia politicians in Ukraine from the Internal Revenue Service, all occurring years before Donald Trump ran for president.

    UN Laughs as Trump Claims US Made Most Strides During His Presidency

    [NATL-NY] UN Laughs as Trump Claims US Made Most Strides During His Presidency

    There was audible laughter in the United Nations General Assembly hall when President Trump said his administration has achieved “more than any other administration in the history of our country," during his address Tuesday. Trump acknowledged as much and responded; “Didn’t expect that reaction but OK.” Read the full story here.

    (Published 5 hours ago)

    Under questioning from Ellis, government lawyers admitted that Manafort had been under investigation for years in the Eastern District of Virginia before Mueller was ever appointed special counsel. And Ellis said it was implausible to think that the charges against Manafort, which primarily concern his business dealings and tax returns from about 2005 through 2015, could have a real connection to Trump's 2016 presidential campaign.

    Ellis suggested the real reason Mueller is pursuing Manafort is to pressure him to "sing" against Trump, though he also noted that such a strategy is a "time-honored practice" for prosecutors and not necessarily illegal. Ellis went on to say that defense lawyers are naturally concerned that defendants in that situation will not only sing but "compose" — meaning that they'll make up facts.

    "You really care about wanting information you could get from Mr. Manafort that would relate to Mr. Trump and lead to his prosecution, or impeachment, or whatever," Ellis said.

    Government lawyer Michael Dreeben said the special counsel's mandate is broad, and that Manafort fits within that jurisdiction because of his connections to both the Trump campaign and to Ukrainian and Russian officials.

    "We needed to understand and explore those relationships and follow the money where it led," Dreeben said.

    Dreeben also argued that the Justice Department has broad discretion to set its own rules for what should be designated to the special counsel's jurisdiction, and that a judge has no role trying to regulate it.

    'Late Night’: A Closer Look at Rosenstein Chaos, Kavanaugh Accuser

    [NATL] 'Late Night’: A Closer Look at Rosenstein Chaos, Kavanaugh Accuser

    Seth Meyers takes a closer look at conflicting news reports about Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein and at the president doubling down on his support for Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh.

    (Published Tuesday, Sept. 25, 2018)

    "We are the Justice Department," Dreeben said of the special counsel's office. "We are not separate from the Justice Department."

    That argument provoked Ellis' ire to an extent and prompted him to question the wisdom of granting unfettered power to a special counsel with a $10 million budget.

    "I'm sure you're sensitive to the fact that the American people feel pretty strongly about no one having unfettered power," Ellis said.

    He asked Dreeben whether the special counsel had already blown through its $10 million budget; Dreeben declined to answer.

    Manafort's lawyer, Kevin Downing, has argued that a special counsel should be tightly constrained in how it operates. He noted that the law authorizing the special counsel was passed to replace the old independent counsel law, which was derided for allowing overbroad, yearslong investigations during the Reagan and Clinton administrations.

    Downing has argued that the charges should be dismissed if Mueller lacked authority to bring them. Ellis, though, suggested another remedy would be to simply hand the case back to regular federal prosecutors.

    Second Kavanaugh Accuser Comes Forward

    [NATL] Second Kavanaugh Accuser Comes Forward

    A second woman accusing Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh of sexual misconduct has come forward, in an interview with The New Yorker. Deborah Ramirez claimed that Kavanaugh pulled down his pants and exposed himself to her at a drinking party when they were both freshmen at Yale, an allegation Kavanaugh denies.

    (Published Monday, Sept. 24, 2018)

    Ellis withheld ruling on the motion and will issue a written ruling at a later date.

    Manafort is also facing a broader indictment in the District of Columbia, where the special counsel has brought the bulk of charges. The tax charges against Manafort had to be brought in Virginia, though, for jurisdictional reasons.

    Manafort's lawyers made similar arguments seeking dismissal to the judge in the District. She has also not yet ruled on the motion.