Woman in ‘Carrie' Costume Totals Car, Terrifies First Responders

"Everyone who was a first responder thought I was dead," said Sidney Wolfe, 20, who hit a deer driving home from an event dressed as "Carrie," the character from the Stephen King novel

A bloodied "Carrie" costume had first responders thinking a woman who totaled her car on an Ohio interstate was in far worse shape than she was.

Sidney Wolfe, 20, was at a haunted house over the weekend dressed as Stephen King's "Carrie," with fake blood covering her face and a white prom dress, an outfit she wore to promote three Halloween productions at a Kentucky theater. 

She was driving home at about 1:45 a.m. when she hit a deer in South Point, Ohio.

"It was so fast and instant. I had no time to react," Wolfe told NBC News on Thursday. "The deer was midair when it flew into my car. I was going 55 mph on the interstate."

She said she warned a 911 dispatcher that when police and medics arrived, she would look more mangled than she actually was. "I said to the responder that I am in full Halloween makeup and don't want them to be frightened," she said.

But the memo wasn't relayed. Wolfe wrote in a now-viral tweet that "everyone who was a first responder thought I was dead," adding an apology in all caps.

Contact Us