Florida

Baby Jesus Statue Stolen From New Jersey Church Nearly a Century Ago Is Anonymously Returned

The church priest said the plaster statue is in great condition after all these years, with “only a chip on the bottom"

A New Jersey church has been reunited with a baby Jesus statue that it said was stolen eight decades ago. Pat Battle reports.

What to Know

  • A New Jersey church has been united with a baby Jesus statue that was supposedly stolen almost a century ago
  • Our Lady of Grace and St. Joseph in Hoboken came across the surprise Wednesday when an unknown package was delivered to its doors
  • The anonymous note, dated Jan. 2, said that the baby Jesus statue was stolen from the church’s Nativity display in the early 1930’s

A New Jersey church has been reunited with a baby Jesus statue that it said was stolen eight decades ago.

Our Lady of Grace and St. Joseph in Hoboken came across the surprise Wednesday when an unknown package was delivered to its doors.

Rev. Alexander Santora, the church priest, said he was initially apprehensive to open the package since it had no return address and it looked like “it was packed by a person” instead of a company. Because of this, Santora decided to call the Hoboken Police Department to report the suspicious package.

Getty Images
NEW YORK, NY - JUNE 14: An Uber SUV waits for a client in Manhattan a day after it was announced that Uber co-founder Travis Kalanick will take a leave of absence as chief executive on June 14, 2017 in New York City. The move came after former attorney general Eric H. Holder Jr. and his law firm, Covington & Burling, released 13 pages of recommendations compiled as part of an investigation of sexual harassment at the ride-hailing car service. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Getty Images

With a heat detecting device, the police department's Emergency Service Unit determined that there was nothing incendiary inside and that the package was safe to open, Santora said.

NBC 4 New York left a message with the Hoboken Police Department's Investigative Bureau, but the bureau did not immediately respond. 

According to Santora, it "was a surprise" when a note and statue were found inside the package.

Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
lfred Mainzer/Curt Teich & Co./Irving Underhill/MCNY
A New York City postcard from 1940.
George Miller, Jr./MCNY
Passage from 1930: "Night — when tired New Yorkers seek the pleasures of the many theatres, night clubs and restaurants to forget the cares of the day."
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
South of Tudor City in Manhattan in 1933.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
General Motors Building from Central Park on a snowy night in 1934.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
Looking south in Times Square from 44th Street in 1932.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
The glimmering lights of Midtown in 1930.
United States Office of War Information/MCNY
Aerial view of Empire State Building in 1944.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
The Financial District from St. George Hotel in 1933.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
The Woolworth Building as seen from the Municipal Building in 1933.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
A view of Times Square's "Whiteway" and the Times Building from 46th Street in 1930.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
Times Square in 1932.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
The Rockefeller Center Christmas tree in Rockefeller Plaza in 1934.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
A view of Midtown from the RCA Building in 1933.
An apartment and office building at 211 East 48th St. in 1934.
New York Edison Company/MCNY
Looking east from Pier 13 in 1928.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
Looking east towards 59th Street from Central Park in 1934.
New York Edison Company/MCNY
The Lower East Side on a snowy night in 1920.
New York Edison Company/MCNY
Columbus Circle in 1928.
New York Edison Company/MCNY
Looking South towards downtown from Canal Street in 1910.
Samuel Herman Gottscho/MCNY
Times Square and Sixth Avenue from the Warwick Hotel in 1930.

A copy of the note dated Jan. 2, which was provided to NBC 4 New York by Santora, said that the baby Jesus statue was stolen from the church’s Nativity display in the early 1930s. According to the sender, the statue somehow came into their grandfather’s possession, and the man never returned it.

“Instead, he gave it to my mother after she was married, and she too kept it until her passing when it came to me. Knowing the story, I felt it should be returned to the rightful owner, and you will find it enclosed,” the note read.

Santora took the note on good faith and welcomed the Baby Jesus back into the church. Santora said the plaster statue is in great condition after all these years, with “only a chip on the bottom.”

The package's postal tracking number traced back to Crystal Springs, Florida, according to Santora.

Though the parish has been in existence since the 19th century and has old statues and relics in storage, Santora is not sure if there any remnants around of the old Nativity scene that corresponds to the baby Jesus statue.

Consumer Reports has ranked America's best and worst grocery stores based on a survey of more than 62,000 Consumer Reports subscribers.
Getty Images
Exit mobile version