A Medford, Massachusetts, insurance agent who police say issued a fake policy to collect the money, allegedly pretended to be her victim before a judge.
Mary Kumar, 26, who works at Prestige Insurance, faces charges including intimidating a witness, forgery and identity fraud.
Officials say Kumar pretended to be the victim in court and that the true victim spent three days in jail as a result of the alleged identity theft.
According to a police report, officials were made aware of customers of Prestige Insurance who were not getting coverage despite paying.
The latest news from around the state
Kumar is due back in court on July 14.